DST 1031 Exchange Calculator
Calculate Delaware Statutory Trust (DST) investment returns for 1031 exchanges. Estimate cash flow, tax deferral benefits, and compare DST vs traditional real estate investments.
Related Calculators
About This Calculator
A Delaware Statutory Trust (DST) is a legal entity that allows multiple investors to hold fractional interests in institutional-quality real estate while qualifying as "like-kind" property for 1031 exchanges. DSTs have become increasingly popular among real estate investors looking to defer capital gains taxes while transitioning from active property management to passive income.
What Is a DST? A DST is a trust formed under Delaware law that holds title to real estate. Investors purchase beneficial interests in the trust, becoming fractional owners of the underlying property. Each DST interest is treated as direct property ownership for 1031 exchange purposes.
Key DST Features:
- Qualifies for 1031 tax-deferred exchanges
- Minimum investments typically $100,000-$250,000
- Completely passive - no management decisions
- Access to institutional-quality properties
- Monthly or quarterly distributions
Who Uses DSTs?
- Investors completing 1031 exchanges
- Landlords tired of property management
- Retirees seeking passive income
- Investors wanting property type diversification
- Those needing to match exact exchange amounts
Important Considerations:
- Accredited investor requirement
- Limited liquidity (typically 5-10 year holds)
- No ability to modify property
- Sponsor quality varies significantly
This calculator helps estimate DST investment returns and tax deferral benefits. For general 1031 exchange planning, see our 1031 Exchange Calculator. For comparing cap rates, visit our Cap Rate Calculator.
How to Use the DST 1031 Exchange Calculator
- 1Enter the amount you plan to invest in the DST.
- 2Select the property type (multifamily, retail, industrial, etc.).
- 3Enter the projected cash-on-cash return (or use default for property type).
- 4Set your expected holding period (5-10 years typical).
- 5Enter expected annual appreciation rate.
- 6Input your original property basis for tax deferral calculation.
- 7Enter the capital gain being deferred via 1031 exchange.
- 8Select your tax bracket for tax savings estimate.
- 9Review annual cash flow and total return projections.
- 10Consider both advantages and risks before investing.
How DSTs Work for 1031 Exchanges
Understanding DST structure and 1031 qualification.
DST Legal Structure
How It Works:
- Sponsor identifies and acquires property
- Property is held in Delaware Statutory Trust
- Trust issues beneficial interests to investors
- Each investor owns fractional interest
- Trust distributes rental income to investors
1031 Exchange Qualification
IRS Revenue Ruling 2004-86:
- DST interests qualify as "like-kind" property
- Must exchange real property for DST interest
- Standard 1031 timelines apply:
- 45 days to identify
- 180 days to close
Advantages for 1031 Exchanges
| Benefit | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Exact amount matching | Invest precise exchange amount |
| Quick closing | Can close in days vs months |
| No debt requirement | Can go from leveraged to unleveraged |
| Backup property | Use as identified property if others fail |
| Diversification | Invest in multiple DSTs |
Example Exchange Flow
- Sell rental property for $1,000,000
- Gain of $400,000 (would owe ~$100,000 in taxes)
- Identify DST within 45 days
- Invest $1,000,000 in DST within 180 days
- Taxes deferred until DST liquidates
- Can 1031 again into another DST at exit
DST Investment Returns
Understanding cash flow and total returns from DST investments.
Typical DST Returns by Property Type
| Property Type | Cash-on-Cash | Appreciation | Total Return |
|---|---|---|---|
| Multifamily | 4.5-5.5% | 2-3% | 6.5-8.5% |
| Net Lease Retail | 5.0-6.0% | 1-2% | 6.0-8.0% |
| Industrial | 4.5-5.5% | 2-4% | 6.5-9.5% |
| Self-Storage | 5.0-6.0% | 2-3% | 7.0-9.0% |
| Medical/Healthcare | 5.5-6.5% | 1-2% | 6.5-8.5% |
| Office | 5.0-6.0% | 0-2% | 5.0-8.0% |
Returns vary significantly by specific deal and market conditions
Return Components
Cash Flow (Distributions)
- Paid monthly or quarterly
- Typically 4-6% annually
- Partially tax-sheltered by depreciation
- Not guaranteed
Appreciation
- Property value increase over time
- Realized at sale/refinance
- Typically 1-4% annually
- Market dependent
Tax Benefits
- Depreciation pass-through
- 1031 exchange capability
- Potential REIT dividend treatment
Comparing DST Returns
$500,000 Investment Over 7 Years:
| Return Source | Amount |
|---|---|
| Cash flow (5% × 7 years) | $175,000 |
| Appreciation (2% × 7 years) | $74,000 |
| Total Return | $249,000 |
| Annualized | ~6.8% |
DST Fees and Costs
Understanding the fee structure of DST investments.
Typical DST Fee Structure
| Fee Type | Typical Amount | When Paid |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront load | 1-3% | At investment |
| Acquisition fee | 1-2% | Built into offering |
| Financing fee | 0.5-1% | At acquisition |
| Asset management | 0.5-1% annually | Ongoing |
| Property management | 3-5% of NOI | Ongoing |
| Disposition fee | 1-3% | At sale |
Total Cost Analysis
On $500,000 Investment:
| Fee | Amount |
|---|---|
| Upfront (2%) | $10,000 |
| Annual (1% × 7 years) | $35,000 |
| Disposition (2%) | $10,000 |
| Total Fees | $55,000 |
| As % of Investment | 11% |
Comparing Fee Impact
$500,000 over 7 years:
| Scenario | Gross Return | Net of Fees |
|---|---|---|
| Before fees (7%) | $401,000 | - |
| After fees | - | $346,000 |
| Fee drag | - | 14% of return |
Evaluating Sponsors
Look For:
- Track record of completed offerings
- Transparent fee disclosure
- Conservative underwriting
- Experienced management team
- Skin in the game (co-investment)
The Seven Prohibited Activities
Understanding DST restrictions that maintain 1031 qualification.
The "Seven Deadly Sins"
To maintain 1031 exchange qualification, DSTs cannot:
1. Accept Additional Capital Contributions
- No additional investment after closing
- Cannot fund capital improvements
- Master lease structures used for reserves
2. Make New Loans
- Cannot refinance existing debt
- Cannot take out additional loans
- Limits flexibility in down markets
3. Renegotiate Lease Terms
- Cannot modify existing leases
- Cannot offer tenant concessions
- Master lease can provide flexibility
4. Renegotiate Loan Terms
- Cannot modify loan terms
- Interest rate changes not allowed
- Limits response to rate environment
5. Make Capital Expenditures
- No major improvements
- Only minor non-structural repairs
- Master lease absorbs these costs
6. Invest Cash Other Than in Certain Ways
- Cash reserves highly restricted
- Must be short-term instruments
- Limited ability to earn on reserves
7. Make More Than Minor Changes
- No development activities
- No major renovations
- Property must remain as acquired
Workarounds: Master Lease Structure
Many DSTs use a master lease:
- Property leased to sponsor affiliate
- Master tenant handles improvements
- Master tenant renegotiates sub-leases
- DST receives stable rent regardless
DST Due Diligence Checklist
Key factors to evaluate before investing in a DST.
Sponsor Evaluation
Research:
- Track record of completed offerings
- Prior deal performance vs. projections
- Investor complaints or litigation
- Experience with property type
- Financial stability
Questions to Ask:
- How many DSTs have you completed?
- What's your average hold period?
- Have any DSTs lost investor capital?
- What's your co-investment in this offering?
Property Analysis
Review:
- Location and market fundamentals
- Tenant credit quality
- Lease terms and expirations
- Property condition report
- Appraisal and valuation
- Environmental reports
Financial Review
Examine:
- Projected vs. achievable returns
- Loan terms and maturity
- Interest rate exposure
- Reserve adequacy
- Sensitivity analysis
- Exit strategy assumptions
Fee Analysis
Compare:
- Total upfront costs
- Ongoing management fees
- Disposition fees
- Related party transactions
- Fee comparison to similar offerings
Red Flags
Warning Signs:
- Unrealistic return projections (>8% cash-on-cash)
- Short track record
- Hidden or unclear fees
- Pressure tactics
- Limited property information
- Unusual legal structure
DST vs. Other Investment Options
Comparing DSTs to alternative investments for 1031 exchangers.
DST vs. Direct Ownership
| Factor | DST | Direct Ownership |
|---|---|---|
| Management | Fully passive | Active required |
| Minimum investment | $100K-250K | Varies widely |
| Control | None | Full |
| Diversification | Easy | Difficult |
| Fees | Higher | Lower |
| Liability | Limited | Personal exposure |
| 1031 flexibility | Excellent | Varies |
DST vs. TIC (Tenants in Common)
| Factor | DST | TIC |
|---|---|---|
| Investor limit | Unlimited | 35 maximum |
| Voting rights | None | Some |
| Loan complexity | Simpler | Complex |
| Exit flexibility | DST sells as unit | Individual can sell |
| 1031 qualification | Clear | Historically yes |
DST vs. REIT
| Factor | DST | REIT |
|---|---|---|
| 1031 eligible | Yes | No |
| Liquidity | Low | High (public) |
| Minimums | $100K+ | $1 (public) |
| Control | None | None |
| Tax treatment | Pass-through | Dividends |
DST vs. UPREIT
| Factor | DST | UPREIT |
|---|---|---|
| 1031 exchange | Yes | 721 exchange |
| Cash flow | Property specific | Diversified |
| Liquidity | Low | Potentially higher |
| Tax deferral | Until sale | Until conversion |
| Complexity | Moderate | Higher |
Decision Framework
Choose DST if:
- Need exact 1031 amount matching
- Want fully passive investment
- Prefer institutional quality
- Value simplicity over control
- Comfortable with illiquidity
Pro Tips
- 💡Research the sponsor's track record extensively before investing.
- 💡Use DSTs for the portion of your exchange needing exact matching.
- 💡Consider diversifying across multiple DSTs rather than one large investment.
- 💡Understand that projected returns are estimates, not guarantees.
- 💡Factor in all fees when calculating expected net returns.
- 💡Keep sufficient liquidity outside DSTs for emergencies.
- 💡Work with a qualified intermediary experienced in DST exchanges.
- 💡Review the Private Placement Memorandum (PPM) thoroughly.
- 💡Consider property type diversification (don't all in one sector).
- 💡Understand the exit timeline aligns with your financial plans.
- 💡Verify accredited investor status meets current requirements.
- 💡Consult with tax and legal advisors before investing.
Frequently Asked Questions
A Delaware Statutory Trust (DST) is a legal entity that holds title to real estate and allows multiple investors to own fractional interests. DSTs qualify as "like-kind" property for 1031 exchanges, allowing investors to defer capital gains taxes while transitioning to passive real estate ownership.
