Auto Loan Calculator

The Dealer Financing Markup Scam

When you get financing through a dealer, there's often a hidden markup you never see. Here's how it works: The bank might approve you at 5% APR (the "buy rate"), but the dealer offers you 7% APR (the "sell rate"). That 2% difference? Pure profit for the dealer, often worth thousands of dollars over the loan's life. This is completely legal, and dealerships make billions from it annually.

How to Beat It:

• Get pre-approved from your bank or credit union before visiting the dealer
• Ask the dealer to beat your pre-approved rate
• If dealer financing is competitive, ask them to disclose their markup
• Never tell the dealer your payment budget - they'll stretch the term to hide higher prices

The 70-Month Loan Epidemic

In January 2026, the average auto loan term exceeds 70 months - almost 6 years. Why does this matter?

• A $40,000 car at 6.5% for 60 months: $782/month, $6,920 total interest
• Same car at 6.5% for 84 months: $591/month, $9,644 total interest

That lower monthly payment costs you an extra $2,724 in interest - and you'll be underwater (owing more than it's worth) for most of the loan.

The "Underwater" Trap

Here's the scary reality: Cars depreciate 20-30% in the first year alone. With minimal down payments and long terms, millions of Americans owe more than their car is worth. When you trade in an underwater vehicle, that negative equity gets rolled into your new loan, making the problem worse. This cycle can trap people in perpetual debt.

The Gold Standard for Car Affordability

Financial experts recommend the 20/4/10 rule for car buying:

20% Down Payment

• Protects against immediate depreciation
• Reduces total interest paid significantly
• Lowers your monthly payment
• Avoids being underwater from day one

4-Year (48-Month) Maximum Term

• Keeps total interest reasonable
• Ensures you build equity faster
• Car paid off while still reliable
• Warranty often covers most issues during this period

10% of Gross Monthly Income

• Total car costs (payment + insurance + fuel) should not exceed 10% of gross income
• If you make $5,000/month, keep total car costs under $500
• Leaves room for savings and emergencies

Real-World Example:

• Income: $60,000/year ($5,000/month)
• Max total car cost: $500/month
• If insurance + fuel = $200/month, max payment = $300
• At 7% for 48 months, max loan = $12,600
• With 20% down ($3,150), max car price = $15,750

Why This Rule Matters: Following 20/4/10 means you'll never be underwater, always have equity, and never stress about car payments. Compare this to the average American who puts 10% down, takes a 70-month loan, and spends 15-20% of income on their vehicle.

The Depreciation Cliff

A new car loses approximately:

• 10% driving off the lot
• 20-30% in the first year
• 40-50% over three years
• 60% over five years

That $50,000 new car? It's worth roughly $37,500 after year one - you've "lost" $12,500.

The Sweet Spot: 2-3 Year Old Cars

Buying a car that's 2-3 years old offers the best value:

• Already taken the biggest depreciation hit
• Still under (or near) manufacturer warranty
• Modern safety and technology features
• Interest rates only 1-2% higher than new

Example Comparison:

• New 2024 Honda Accord: $30,000
• 2021 Honda Accord (30k miles): $22,000
• Savings: $8,000 (27%)
• Same car, just 3 years older

When New Makes Sense:

• 0% financing available (if you'd invest the savings)
• You plan to keep it 10+ years
• Specific safety features only in new models
• Business depreciation deductions

When Used Makes Sense:

• Budget-conscious buyers
• First-time car buyers
• Secondary vehicles
• High-mileage drivers

Dealer Financing

• Pros: Convenience, occasional 0% offers
• Cons: Often marked up, pressure tactics
• Best for: Those with excellent credit who can negotiate

Bank/Credit Union

• Pros: Usually lower rates, pre-approval locks in rate
• Cons: Requires separate application
• Best for: Most buyers - gives negotiating leverage

Manufacturer Financing (Captive Lenders)

• Pros: Promotional 0% or low rates on select models
• Cons: Often requires forgoing rebates
• Best for: When special financing > rebate value

Online Lenders

• Pros: Competitive rates, easy comparison
• Cons: Less negotiating leverage at dealer
• Best for: Tech-savvy buyers, refinancing

Buy Here Pay Here (AVOID)

• APR: Often 20-30%+
• Typically targets subprime buyers
• High default rates, aggressive repossession
• Alternative: Credit union "second chance" programs

Current Rate Landscape (January 2026):

Note: Rates improved slightly in late 2025 after the Fed cut rates 75 basis points

What is GAP Insurance? GAP (Guaranteed Asset Protection) covers the difference between what you owe on your loan and what your car is worth if it's totaled or stolen. Example: You owe $25,000, car is worth $20,000, and it's totaled. Regular insurance pays $20,000, leaving you with a $5,000 bill. GAP covers that difference.

When You NEED GAP:

• Down payment less than 20%
• Loan term longer than 48 months
• Leasing (usually required)
• High-depreciation vehicles
• Rolling negative equity from previous car

When You DON'T Need GAP:

• 20%+ down payment
• 48-month or shorter loan
• Buying used (already depreciated)
• Car worth more than you owe

Where to Buy GAP (Price Comparison):

• Dealer: $500-1,000 (most expensive)
• Your auto insurer: $20-40/year ($80-160 over 4 years)
• Credit union: Often free or $200-300

Key Insight: Never buy GAP at the dealer. Your auto insurance company offers the same coverage for 1/3 to 1/5 the cost. The dealer's GAP is often marked up 300%+ and financed into your loan, meaning you pay interest on it too.

Current Interest Rate Environment:

Market Dynamics:

• Fed rate cuts in late 2025 have begun easing auto loan rates
• New car inventory recovered, reducing markups
• Used car prices down 15% from 2022 peak but still elevated
• Average new car payment: $738/month (record high)
• Average used car payment: $528/month

EV Loan Considerations:

• Some lenders offer 0.5-1% lower rates for EVs
• EV depreciation varies widely by brand
• Tesla holds value better than most EVs
• Used EV market growing but uncertain residuals

Manufacturer Incentives (2026):

Strategy: Shop during model year changeovers (August-October) for best financing deals on outgoing models.

EV Cost Comparison:

Total Cost of Ownership Example (5 Years):

• 2026 Tesla Model 3: $42,000 - $7,500 credit = $34,500 + $15K operating = $49,500
• 2026 Honda Accord: $31,000 + $22K operating = $53,000

EV Financing Considerations:

1. Battery degradation: Factor into resale value estimates
2. Charging infrastructure: Home charging saves vs public charging
3. Range anxiety: May need second vehicle for some households
4. Insurance costs: Often 10-25% higher for EVs
5. Residual uncertainty: EV resale values less predictable

When EV Financing Makes Sense:

• High annual mileage (15K+ miles/year)
• Access to home charging
• State has strong EV incentives
• Plan to keep vehicle 7+ years
• Electricity rates under $0.15/kWh

When Gas Still Wins:

• Low annual mileage (<10K/year)
• No home charging access
• Frequent long-distance trips
• Tight budget (used gas cars still cheaper)
• High electricity rates

1. Get Pre-Approved First Walk into the dealer with a rate in hand. This:

• Gives you negotiating leverage
• Removes financing as a confusion tactic
• Lets you focus purely on price
• Shows you're a serious buyer

2. Negotiate the Total Price, Not the Payment Dealers love to ask "What monthly payment fits your budget?" This lets them:

• Extend the term to lower payment
• Hide a higher price in a longer loan
• Sneak in add-ons

Instead, negotiate the out-the-door price, then discuss financing separately.

3. Time Your Purchase Best times to buy:

• End of month (salespeople need quotas)
• End of quarter (manufacturer incentives)
• End of year (clearing inventory)
• Monday-Wednesday (less busy, more attention)

4. Consider a Shorter Term $30,000 loan comparison:

• 72 months at 7%: $511/mo, $6,788 interest
• 48 months at 7%: $718/mo, $4,482 interest
• Savings: $2,306 (and paid off 2 years sooner)

5. Round Up Payments Instead of $487.26, pay $500 or $550. Extra goes to principal, saving hundreds in interest and months of payments.

6. Refinance When Rates Drop If your credit improves or rates drop, refinancing can save significantly. Rule of thumb: refinance if you can drop 2%+ and have at least 24 months remaining.